Reviews

Rate Show

Personalities
I really like Alex and Mac’s personalities. They provide a balance of enthusiastic nerdiness and and whimsy! I like it when people aren’t bogged down by the realities of real world and can just come up with a clever variety of theories… I like their enthusiasm for Ashoka, which I’m really enjoying! Thanks for the entertaining podcasts and keep up the good work!

Keep. The. Watch. Period.
I’m a huge Star Wars nerd, but these guys have me beat, and I love it! I love they point out all the Easter eggs I miss and what not. Great after-show! Must have for any level of fandom. My favorite after show of 8 different ones I’m subscribed to. 😁

My favorite Star Wars centric podcast
Jumped into the show this summer in anticipation of Ahsoka and it has not disappointed. I had watched all the feloni verse shows but used this pod as a way to catch up on the rebels and mandalorian storylines I may have forgotten going into the new series. The hosts have a lot of knowledge while not being too bogged down in the details of it all so it’s consumable for someone that only has a bit of Star Wars lore in their head. My only real complaint of the show would be Mac’s constant need to nervously laugh at the end of any theory or sentence he is not 100% sure of. He frequently ends his sentences with an awkward laugh as if he is unsure about what he just said or how it will be received. Mac, you have a lot of bona fides and a large podcast with a ton of support- say what you mean and say it with confidence.

Voicemail Screamer
What I love most about this podcast is how much the hosts embrace the fun and wonder of the Star Wars universe simply for the sake of enjoyment.

So much knowledge
I love listening to these guys. Their in depth knowledge of all things Star Wars provides so much insight. This is a must listen for Fans of all things Star Wars or the casual fan who just watches new material.

Great Scene by Scene Pod Review of Star Wars Shows
Alex and Mac bring it every show, well done gentlemen. If you enjoy a journey of going through scene by scene view and analyzing points of view for the scene this is pod for you. Keep up the great work. Can’t wait for next week’s episode.

These guys are great!
Simply put, this is worth listening to.

This is THE way! And more!
I’ve listen to a lot of Mandalorian podcast but these guys just do it the best! Update: These guys continue to nail the Star Wars universe!

Great way to enjoy Star Wars!
Really fun way to follow up watching Star Wars tv!

Awesome Star Wars pod
Alex and Mac are knowledgeable in all things Star Wars and make great connections and insights about the newest Star Wars shows. They often point out inconsistencies or questionable storylines with a good natured laugh but are never overly critical. And still they can express differing viewpoints without contentiousness. What an awesome force ability in these polarizing times! They genuinely love Star Wars (who wouldn’t!). My favorite SW pod hands down.

Rad podcast!!!
A week into the podcast and it could be said that this is the best Star Wars podcast!!!

Just Star Wars!
Love these guys! Definitely my new favorite Star Wars related podcast. Y’all have some great thoughts and ideas! Talk about the topics like true fans! And you keep it Star Wars. No politics or outside stuff. Just what we are here for. Keep it up!!!

My Favorite Star Wars Poscast
I love listening to this podcast every week! They are so thorough and give lots of background info but not too much. Also they give great recommendations on other books and shows to check out if you want to go deeper. Thanks guys for being awesome.

Great podcast
Amazing, deep knowledge and background. Very literary guys who break down these episodes like an advanced literature class professor would do in college. Request: keep talking about the Mandalorian plot line going on at the same time as Ahsoka. Is the whole Thrawn cult and supporters running in parallel track to the Moff Gideon program or the expanded Moff leadership circle trying to get Palpatine back? In other words, is there a group trying to bring back Empire power back under Thrawn instead of under Palpatine?

This is the Way
Good clean fun,. Great insight into the Mandoverse and all things Star Wars. At first I thought this podcast would be to nerdy for me, but I’m totally hooked and these guys have got me reading the old, Expanded Universe, Thrawn books. Now I’m the Star Wars nerd and LOVING it 😝

Fan forever for knowledge and values
I am updating my review. I love listening to these two guys. Talk about Star Wars. They’re knowledgeable, they clearly love it, and the podcast is fun listen. I listen to several Star Wars podcast. This is my first go to after every episode.

Great! But……
Love the show and the content. It’s fun and informative to listen in conjunction with watching the shows. My wife and I really love to listen to it on our car rides (We have listened since the first season of the Mandolarian back when it was called The Mandolorian Watch) This is where my only problem with this podcast comes up. You NEED to do something about Mac’s volume levels in is microphone. I don’t know what it is if he is mumbling, not talking into his microphone, bad equipment, or whatever. It is detrimental to the listening experience when we have to max out the volume most of the time Mac speaks and then turn it down so our ears don’t bleed from Alex, voice line callers, and the music being at acceptable levels. Please do something about this because we like what Mac has to say (if we can hear him) and it makes the listening experience bad for us if we can’t hear him. It bothered us so much that we couldn’t finish the first hotline episode for Ashoka (which is sad). I write this review to support the podcast with five stars because we love it. We also have trust that they see we have to say and are constantly improving to give every listener a terrific experience. Thank you Alex and Mac for what you do.

Best podcast in the galaxy!
I’m a big star wars podcast listener and have been listening to Mando Watch since day 1, among several others. This is by far the best star wars TV podcast out there. Mac and Alex are excellent, and they know their stuff inside out. Super helpful backstory info and conversations if you missed or forgot details from the past - even including the old EU - and great insights into what is yet to come. This podcast is truly the way. Thank you, and “Keep the watch!!!” August 2023 update - this show only gets better with time. Loving the Ahsoka coverage!!!

Baby yoda
Amazing and positive Star Wars content! I’m so happy you guys have sponsors now! You really really deserve it!

Fun show with great insight!
These guys put so much work and love into their episodes and it shows. I came here in the middle of season 2 of the Mandalorian and have been listening every week since. Can’t wait to see where Ahsoka and the Star Wars universe goes, and the breakdowns that will follow. Keep up the great work!

Great show
Fun and informative show to listen to for both the newcomer and seasoned fan in the Star Wars Universe

Love the show
Thank you for the content, always make me think about Stat Wars differently

These guys rock Star Wars
Top Star Wars podcast. Great insight. Always stoked

Asoka
Thank you guys for always saying great things about the shows you break down. The negativity from other podcasts can only hurt getting more content for us. Not every show is perfect but I had to shut off other podcasts due to I don’t care why they didn’t like this or that. I loved Asoka. I thought Dave Filoni did a great job. Listening to you it really enhanced my feelings for it. You guys are the very first podcast I ever listened to when I wanted more about the Mandolorian series. You are still my favorite for history and teasing out the story on all things Star Wars. I was 20 years old when a new Hope came out. Now in my 60’s I share stars wars with my grandson. He sometimes asks me character questions lol. I say it’s a but universe but I shall find out from COTW.

Just really good
I like the hotline and how you engage with fans

ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!
This is exactly what I was looking for after my family yelled at me for over-analyzing EVERYTHING Star Wars. Now I can talk to people and get good theories too! Great job!

The Best Vibes
Been listening since they started doing Mando recaps, I love this podcast cause it’s all positive vibes and helps to nurture my joy of Star Wars instead of making me sad that people are hating on something I love so much ! Best vibes hands down and super fun and informative !

Detailed and Entertaining.
These guys have an amazingly encyclopedic knowledge of everything Star Wars. Listening to the podcast really brings out things that a casual Star Wars fan would never get just from watching the show. I love that they go through each episode, scene by scene, and point out the importance of everything that occurs. Great show!